Dental Discount Plan vs Dental Insurance: Which Saves You More?
A dental discount plan lowers your prices at participating dentists, while dental insurance pays part of your bill up to a yearly cap. Discount plans do not pay any dental expenses for you, so they work best when you need work soon or want a low fixed fee.
Affiliate disclosure: some links earn BetterGrin a commission at no extra cost to you. Picks never depend on payout.
What is the difference between a dental discount plan and dental insurance?
Insurance pays claims. A discount plan only cuts the price. Insurance has a monthly premium and pays for covered services until the annual benefit maximum, typically $1,000 to $2,000, while discount plans charge a membership fee and give lower prices from participating dentists.
| Dental insurance | Discount plan | |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | Pays part of covered care | Lowers your price at network dentists |
| Typical cost | $20 to $50 a month | About $150 a year |
| Waiting periods | Common for major work | Generally none |
| Yearly cap | Typically $1,000 to $2,000 | None |
| Typical savings | Plan pays a share of covered care | 10% to 60% off at participating dentists |
Are dental discount plans cheaper than insurance?
Usually, yes. A single-person policy typically costs $20 to $50 a month, while an average discount plan fee runs about $150 a year (about $12.50 a month).
Price per month is only half the story. Discount plans still leave you paying the discounted price for every procedure, and insurance may cover a bigger share of expensive care if you stay under the cap.
Is dental insurance worth it?
It can be, depending on the premium and how much care you use. You may come out ahead by paying for insurance, but only if you actually use the benefits and get to the dentist for routine care.
If you spend $0 on dental care today because you skip visits, a plan adds cost at first. Routine care can help avoid major dental care down the road.
How do you decide between them?
Use a discount plan if you need major work soon, dislike waiting periods, or want a low fixed fee. Choose insurance if you want help with routine care and can wait out the plan's rules.
- 1Get a written treatment plan with prices from your dentist.
- 2Ask which discount plans and insurance networks your dentist accepts.
- 3Call two network dentists and ask for actual charges. The discount depends on the dentist.
- 4Add up the year: fee or premiums plus what you would still pay. Compare totals, not percentages.
- 5Run your numbers in the insurance vs cash tool.
Quick answers
Do dental discount plans have waiting periods?
Generally no. Discount plans typically have no deductibles, no waiting periods, and no annual maximums.
Is a dental discount plan real insurance?
No. It does not pay claims. It gives discounted prices at participating dentists in exchange for a membership fee.
Is it cheaper to get dental insurance or pay out of pocket?
It depends on how much care you need. Compare yearly premiums plus your share of costs against the cash price. The insurance vs cash tool runs the math for you.
What is a dental insurance annual maximum?
It is the most your plan pays in a plan year. Past that, you pay 100% until the next year.
Run the numbers for your own mouth
Compare plan fees against your actual treatment costs before you sign up.
Open Insurance vs CashBetterGrin shares general dental education. It does not diagnose conditions or replace care from a licensed dentist or doctor. Costs and plan terms vary by plan, state, and provider.